1Password vs Proton Pass: Best Password Manager in 2025?

Are you tired of juggling passwords?

It’s a real pain, right? 

So, you’re looking for a password manager, and 1Password vs Proton Pass has caught your eye. 

But which one is actually the best for you in 2025?

This article dives deep, comparing their key features, security, and ease of use.

We’ll break down 1Password vs Proton Pass simply so you can make the smart choice and finally ditch those sticky notes!

Overview

To bring you this clear comparison, we’ve spent time exploring both 1Password and Proton Pass.

We examined their ease of use every day, examined their security features, and compared what you get for your money.

This hands-on experience helps us highlight the real differences.

What is 1Password?

So, what’s the deal with 1Password?

It’s like a super secure digital vault for all your logins and sensitive info.

Think of it as your internet bodyguard.

Also, explore our favorite 1Password alternatives…

Key Benefits

• Securely stores unlimited passwords.
• Identifies 80% of weak or reused passwords.
• Offers 2-factor authentication for extra security.
• It makes secure sharing with family and teams easy.
• Autofills logins on all your devices.

Pricing

• Teams Starter Pack: $19.95/month
• Business: $7.99/month
• Enterprise: Contact sales for custom pricing
• Individual: $2.99/month
• Families: $4.99/month

What is Proton Pass?

Now, let’s talk about Proton Pass.

It comes from the folks behind ProtonMail, known for their focus on privacy.

It aims to be a secure and private way to manage your passwords.

Key Benefits

• Offers a generous free plan.
• Provides unlimited password storage.
• Features a unique email alias creation.
• Employs end-to-end encryption.
• It is open-source and auditable.

Pricing

• Free: €0/month
• Proton Plus: €2.99/month
• Proton Family: €4.99/month
• Proton Unlimited: €9.99/month

Feature Comparison

Let’s get down to the nitty-gritty.

We’re going to look at what each password manager can actually do.

This will help you see which one has the stuff you really need.

1. Password Storage

1Password provides a secure place to store all your usernames and passwords.

It remembers them for you so you don’t have to. 

Proton offers the same basic thing: a digital vault for your logins.

Both make it easier to sign in to websites and apps.

2. Password Generation

Need a super strong new password?

1Password can make one up for you.

It creates passwords that are really hard for bad guys to guess.

Using Proton, you can also generate a strong, random password.

This helps you stay more secure online.

3. Autofill

Tired of typing in your passwords all the time?

1Password offers autofill.

This means when you go to a website, it can fill in your username & password for you.

Proton also offers this helpful feature, making logging in much faster.

4. Security Features

Keeping your info safe is super important.

1Password offers strong encryption to protect your data.

It also has two-factor authentication for added security.

Proton offers similar security with encryption.

Plus, because it’s from the makers of ProtonMail, privacy is a big deal for them.

5. Password Health

Want to know if your passwords are safe?

1Password has a feature called password health.

It checks your passwords and tells you if any are weak or have been in a data breach.

Proton also offers a way to check the strength of your passwords.

6. Advanced Storage

Besides just passwords, 1Password offers some extra goodies.

You can easily store secure notes, credit card details, & other sensitive info.

Proton offers some extras, too, such as its focus on privacy and the option for email aliases.

Interestingly, Proton also has a proton calendar for managing your schedule securely.

7. Ease of Use

1Password generally gets good marks for being user-friendly.

It’s usually not too hard to figure out how to save and use your passwords.

Using Proton is also pretty straightforward, especially if you’re already familiar with other Proton services.

What to Look For When Choosing The Right Password Manager?

• Security First: Does it use strong encryption? What additional security features does it have, like two-factor authentication (2FA)?
• Ease of Use: Is the app and browser extension easy to understand? How smoothly does the autofill feature work across different devices?
• Features You Need: Does it offer secure note storage or other extras? Do you need family sharing or business features?
• Cost and Value: Does it fit your budget? What do you get for the price (free vs. paid)?
• Privacy Practices: What kind of data does the company collect? Do they have a good track record on user privacy?

Final Verdict

We think 1Password is better overall. It has more useful features.

Autofill works very well, and it works great on Android, too.

Proton Pass is a decent choice; it’s also good if you value privacy.

It works with Proton VPN, but 1Password now has more features.

But for the best password managers, 1Password is the winner. 

It makes password management easy and safe.

We know these tools well.

1Password is consistently great.

1Password Compared

Here’s a quick look at 1Password compares:

• 1Password vs Passpack: Passpack feels older; 1Password offers a more modern and intuitive experience.
• 1Password vs NordPass: NordPass is simpler to use, while 1Password provides a wider range of advanced features.
• 1Password vs Keeper Security: Both provide robust security measures; 1Password is often praised for its user interface.
• 1Password vs LastPass: LastPass’s free plan has limitations; 1Password provides consistent features across its paid tiers.
• 1Password vs TotalPassword: TotalPassword is a newer option, while 1Password has a longer and more established reputation.
• 1Password vs Dashlane: Dashlane includes a built-in VPN in some plans; 1Password concentrates on excellent password management.
• 1Password vs RoboForm: RoboForm excels at form filling, while 1Password is stronger in secure password management and organization.

Proton Pass Compared

Let’s see how Proton Pass stacks up against some alternatives:

• Proton Pass vs Passpack: Passpack has been around longer; Proton Pass offers a more modern, privacy-focused approach with email aliases.
• Proton Pass vs NordPass: NordPass has a simpler interface, while Proton Pass provides a free tier and strong encryption from the Proton ecosystem.
• Proton Pass vs Keeper Security: Keeper Security offers extensive business features, while Proton Pass focuses on individual privacy and has a user-friendly free plan.
• Proton Pass vs LastPass: LastPass has a longer history, but it has also faced security concerns. Proton Pass is newer, with a strong emphasis on security and open-source principles.
• Proton Pass vs TotalPassword: TotalPassword is a newer, simpler option; Proton Pass offers a free plan and unique features like email aliasing.
• Proton Pass vs Dashlane: Dashlane offers a built-in VPN in some plans, while Proton Pass prioritizes privacy and provides integrated email aliases.
• Proton Pass vs RoboForm: RoboForm excels at form filling, while Proton Pass focuses on secure password management and privacy features.

Frequently Asked Questions